A woman was found unresponsive on a desert highway and brought to the emergency room of a local hospital. After five days in a coma, the woman awoke and did not know her name, where she was from, her history, or have any recollection of her past. She was given the name Jane Brown and eventually released from the hospital. After many years working with social service agencies, she built a new life but never regained memories of her past. Eventually, she graduated college, moved to the Pacific Northwest, married, and had two sets of twins one year apart. One day a man recognized her as a missing woman from Arizona and contacted authorities. The police notified Ms. Brown of her past life and informed her she has family members who want to meet her. With the hope of remembering her past, she met with them. With the case receiving national news coverage and attention, the local hospital noticed a marked increase in the number of people requesting access to the health records of Ms. Brown and her children.
· Discuss the ethical issues associated with this case
· Identify a few things the hospital can do to prevent unethical behavior
· Discuss Ms. Brown’s potential ethical cultural shock by learning who she was and meeting family and friends who she does not remember. Think in terms of religion and cultural bias or prejudices.
1 page, approx 200 word
How to solve
Ethics and standards of practice Nursing Assignment Help
Introduction:
The case scenario presented involves a woman named Jane Brown who was found unresponsive and brought to the emergency room, later waking up with no memory of her past. Over time, she built a new life, but was recognized as a missing person and informed about her past, leading to increased interest in accessing her health records. This raises ethical issues and questions regarding privacy, informed consent, and potential cultural shock. This answer will discuss the ethical issues associated with the case, suggest preventive measures for the hospital to avoid unethical behavior, and examine the potential ethical cultural shock experienced by Ms. Brown.
1. Ethical issues associated with the case:
The first ethical issue in this case is the invasion of privacy. With the news of Ms. Brown’s past becoming national coverage, there was a marked increase in the number of people requesting access to her and her children’s health records. This raises concerns about the unauthorized disclosure of personal and medical information. Patients have the right to expect confidentiality, and any breach of this trust can undermine their autonomy and the integrity of the healthcare system.
Another ethical issue is the potential violation of informed consent. If Ms. Brown’s health records were accessed without her knowledge or consent, it would be a direct violation of her right to control the disclosure of her personal information. Healthcare providers have a moral and legal obligation to obtain informed consent before accessing or disclosing medical records, and any breach of this principle undermines patient autonomy and trust.
2. Preventive measures for the hospital to prevent unethical behavior:
To prevent unethical behavior and maintain patient privacy, the hospital should implement strict protocols and safeguards. One measure is the enforcement of robust data protection policies. This includes restricting access to health records only to authorized personnel who have a legitimate need for the information. Additionally, the hospital can introduce regular training for healthcare staff to increase awareness of privacy laws, ethical considerations, and the importance of maintaining patient confidentiality.
Another preventive measure is the implementation of secure technology systems that protect patient data from unauthorized access. This includes implementing strong encryption protocols, regularly updating security measures, and conducting audits to identify any potential vulnerabilities.
3. Ms. Brown’s potential ethical cultural shock:
Learning about her past and meeting family and friends whom she does not remember can lead to a significant ethical cultural shock for Ms. Brown. Religion and cultural bias or prejudices can play a role in this experience. For instance, if Ms. Brown belongs to a specific religious or cultural background that she was not previously aware of, she may have conflicting beliefs or struggle to reconcile her new identity with her existing values.
It is essential to support Ms. Brown during this process by providing culturally sensitive counseling and guidance. Healthcare professionals should aim to understand her cultural background, respect her beliefs and values, and address any potential conflicts that may arise. It is crucial to create a safe environment where Ms. Brown can freely express herself, ask questions, and explore her identity without fear of judgment or exclusion.
Conclusion:
The case of Jane Brown raises several ethical considerations, including privacy breaches, informed consent violations, and potential cultural shock. To uphold ethical standards, hospitals should prioritize patient confidentiality, enforce data protection measures, and provide culturally sensitive support for individuals encountering significant identity changes. It is essential for healthcare professionals to navigate such complex situations with empathy, respect, and a commitment to patient autonomy.
